Horse Slaughter Suit Hits USDA, HSUS

Meat company sues USDA and HSUS over horse slaughter.

More About:

A Roswell, NM, meat company has filed suit against USDA over a lack of action on a request for inspections that would clear the way for the company to resume domestic horse slaughterhouse operations in an effort to revitalize horse meat food services to foreign buyers.

Company owner Rick de los Santos says the company is still waiting for federal action though the lawsuit was filed last October. Federal court officials say USDA has until January to respond to the request but confirm they will continue to process the lawsuit in the interim.

Valley Meat Company is suing the federal government, alleging USDA inaction on its application has cost the company “hundreds of thousands of dollars” in recent months. The company has also filed suit against advocates for the humane treatment of animals, who de los Santos claims defamed his business during what he termed “an expensive, yearlong fight” over his proposal. That suit names the Humane Society of the U.S., Front Range Equine Rescue, and Animal Protection of New Mexico as plaintiffs.

To read the entire article, click here.

Discuss this Article 20

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jan 9, 2013

I think they should resume horse slaughter as a means of disposing of unwanted animals. There seems to be a large amount of these around

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jan 9, 2013

that's gross. Slaughter is for food production, it should not be used as a disposal method for "unwanted animals" that suddenly turns them into a "food source" for the consumer markets. Horses are not raised as a food source by dedicated producers, under food safety guidelines and protocols. Americas Horses Bred & Used For Sport, Recreation,Work,Competition and Racing Have NO place in the Human Food Chain. Horse owners are not regulated or restricted from using Drugs/Medications that are banned for use in all other food producing animals, nor is there any traceability system to determine where the majority of USA horses have been, or what drugs they have received over their lifetime..I'd be willing to bet if all other meats were sourced in the same manner, those markets would collapse pretty quickly. Not many Consumers would be willing to spend their hard earned money on meats that came from..who knows where,and has who knows what in it..USA could never afford to target test every single horse carcass for residuals of banned substances such as bute & clen, these drugs are used commonly in the Horse Industry...Chances are the great majority of Horse meat produced by the random gathering of Horses by Killbuyers , would result in adulterated -tainted meats not fit for Human Consumption. ..

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jan 9, 2013

Just what do you think we should do with all the unwanted horses in this country? Spend billions so they can have a social security system like the wild horses have? Think about it.

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jan 9, 2013

Every intentionally Breed Domestic Horse in This Country Has an OWNER. If The owner does not "want' Their Horse they can Sell or Give to someone that does, if they can not sell or rehome "their" horse(s) they can have their Horse(s) Humanely Euth'd and Bury,compost or send for rendering..they can also drop their horse(s) where they stand/butcher for their own use or take to a custom meat locker and butcher for their own personal consumption if they so choose. Industrial Slaughter is for food it ,is not population control , nor should "unwanted" animals be a source of food, simply because they are "unwanted"..Breeding programs that reflect the economy and market place are the most effective means to control an over population of "unwanteds" and have been ignored for to long by many, not having the "disposal option" of slaughter for a "salvage fee" will get the attention of those breeders, once they are forced to deal with what they have bred in a market that does not support horse ownership as it did years ago, due to high unemployment, foreclosures, an aging sector of former horse owners, kids that would rather ride 4 wheelers, escalating feed & hay prices,and so on. We don't send Cattle,Hogs,Pigs,Lambs,Chickens, etc. to Slaughter to supply the Consumer Markets simply because there are "to many" or they are "unwanted" Horses should not be the exception. Think about it. (anon-kh)

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jan 9, 2013

What is wrong with putting the horse down in the meadow and then a rendering company? Oh - No Money in it for the Kill Buyers- Put the horses through a cruxifiction - have you seen the ACTUAL SLAUGHTER VIDEOS? This is torture and it isn't made up- Unwanted horses - you mean the ones starving to death in the kill pens or the ones trampled to death in the illegal wild horses roundups? The only reason ANYONE wants slaughter is for MONEY or else there would be alot more "cowboys and cowgirls" helping out, not hitting them in the head with a sledge hammer to make a couple of hundred dollars- Man Up - this is about MONEY that is the ONLY reason -

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jan 10, 2013

"Unwanted" animals—turned into food. if you want to kill the beef (and other industries) this is the way to do it.

Bad idea.

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jan 9, 2013

Horse-Slaughter was & is & will never be Humun. What are we going to do next, slaughter our overpopulated dogs & cats to feed foriegn-countries? Aw come on, give me a break.
67-70% Canadians oppose to H-Slaughter & 80% Americans, also. Watch & find out for yourselves how inhumun H-Slaughter is and how toxic, this meat can be in the long run. Horses are NOT raised for consumption, they are PETS.
LINK - Richelieu Video Summary Part III of III ://youtu.be/M4th6b-IP9k

VIA/ In late February 2010, the Canadian Horse Defence Coalition (CHDC) received hidden camera footage of horse slaughter practices at Quebecs Viandes Richelieu and Albertas Bouvry Exports - the latter known as North Americas largest exporter of horsemeat.

The CHDC has asked a panel of veterinarians, the BC SPCA and the World Society for the Protection of Animals to review the footage, which contains numerous instances of improper stunning and horses showing signs of returning consciousness.

Early audit results of the footage show automatic failures of both facilities.

As there are only two government-approved methods of stunning horses in Canada - captive bolt gun and rifle - and both methods have been shown to cause prolonged suffering in numerous horses, we conclude that these animals cannot be slaughtered humanely in todays slaughterhouse assembly lines.

The CHDC therefore calls for the immediate closure of Canadas horse slaughter plants.
Support BILL C-322!
Thanks. ~

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jan 9, 2013

Slaughter of Horses was a nessessary tool of the Horse industry as a whole, to keep it economicly sound as it disposed of the the aged,disabled,untrainable and unwanted individuals who were of no use in the general population.By and large horses are a use animal for livestock operations ,racing,showing,breeding and pleasure mounts and are not considered "pets" by professionals with in the industry. It is only the occasional users, "city slicks", and animal rights fanatics that really consider horses to be pets and treat them as such.By taking away the fuctions of slaughter houses the nessessary manner to eliminating the unwanted horses in our society has caused a huge injury to the industy as a whole and until that source of elimination is resolved and fully funtioning again horses shall continue to be abused as has never happened in history until the do- gooders eliminated horse slaughter.Any intelligent individual who has functioned within the horse industry can clearly see the significant escalation of animal abuse cases across the country wheather true or imagined by do-gooders who have no vested interest in the true welfare of horses since the elimination of slaughter houses as a nessessary means of disposing of sick or unwanted horses.

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jan 9, 2013

oh yummy, meat from "sick" horses!

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jan 9, 2013

SO You Want to SEND SIck and Unwanted diseased horses to slaughter so the meat can be sold to the children in the EU market? What are we a third world country? Hey let's put rat poison in baby formula to make money - Wait - China already scoped us on that. Can you spell cancer in children in Ireland called Leukemia from chemicals in Or do you enjoy eating wormer with your bute? Sure let's make money off kids?

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jan 10, 2013

And how much money do you reckon you'll personally be pocketing by sending your horses to slaughter?

How much do you want the rest of us to put up so you can do it?

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jan 9, 2013

Where we live there are many unwanted horses, but no real way to dispose of them. Because of the economic situation and the prolonged western drought, owners can no longer afford to feed them. The lucky ones are given away to someone who has the resources to care for them. The others are standing in mud lots with their ribs sticking out. Local animal control is doing the best they can to collect these and get them adopted or sent to rescue people but both of those groups are financially strapped, too.

I agree that any horse from recreational or racing origins needs to have a rather lengthy waiting period to make sure that any drugs, anhelminthics or other medications and treatments have cleared and I am not sure whether USDA has set up the appropriate precautions yet. I have read that this was recently a problem with some horse meat processed in Mexico and sent to Europe.

On our farm we have the finances to be able to euthanise and dispose of an older or sick animal that is in pain, but many folks do not. Where we farm the disposal often costs more than the vet. euthanasia. I have seen animals put down with a rifle and it is just as humane as an injection if done properly. I cannot comment on the bolt method as I have never seen it used on equines.

Horse rescue groups are great outfits that do excellent work, and I really wish more people would send their donations to them rather than to the political groups like HSUS. That would at least help to alleviate the problem, since the $$ go directly to the problem.

Still, the problem will remain of what to do with the huge numbers of horses out west which cannot be adopted. It would seem there are two choices; slaughter or euthanasia and disposal. The first choice is more economical since there is a market for the meat, but aforementioned problems regarding drug and other residues is a definite issue along with making sure that all treatment is as humane as possible.

The second choice, euthanasia and disposal is much more expensive but definitely humane and guarantees no residues enter the food chain either here or overseas, but who can afford to do this? It's a tough problem right now. Since it really hurts me to see animals suffering in dirt lots I have to say that I could support horse slaughter but only if the appropriate safety and humane handling issues are solved.

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jan 9, 2013

Substances Found/Used in nearly every barn/stable and Banned for use in Meat Producing Animals: Drugs prohibited for use in horses intended for human consumption

Ingredient Name: phenylbutazone
Trade Names: Phenylzone (Schering), Bute Tabs (Vedco), Phenylbute (Phoenix Pharmaceutical)

Phenylbutazone (commonly referred to as "bute") is currently approved only for oral and injectable use in dogs and horses. Use in horses is limited to use in horses not intended for food. There are currently no approved uses of phenylbutazone in food-producing animals.

http://www.fda.gov/OHRMS/DOCKETS/98fr/03-4741.htm

Ingredient Name: acepromazine maleate
Trade Name: PromAce (Fort Dodge)
http://www.fda.gov/downloads/AnimalVeterinary/Products/ApprovedAnimalDru...
http://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/animaldrugsatfda/details.cfm?dn=01...

Ingredient Name: boldenone undecylenate
Trade Name: Equipoise (Fort Dodge)
http://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/animaldrugsatfda/details.cfm?dn=03...

Ingredient Name: omeprazole
Trade Name: GastroGard
http://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/animaldrugsatfda/details.cfm?dn=14...

Ingredient Name: ketoprofen
Trade Name: Ketofen (Fort Dodge)
http://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/animaldrugsatfda/details.cfm?dn=14...

Ingredient Name: ivermectin
Trade Names: EQVALAN (Merial), Zimecterin (Merial), Equell (Pfizer), IverCare (Farnam)
EQVALAN: http://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/animaldrugsatfda/details.cfm?dn=13...
Zimecterin: http://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/animaldrugsatfda/details.cfm?dn=13...

Ingredient Name: xylazine HCl
Trade Names: Anased (Lloyd), Sedazine (Fort Dodge), Xyla-Ject (Phoenix Pharmaceutical)
http://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/animaldrugsatfda/details.cfm?dn=14...

Ingredient Name: hyaluronic acid (sodium hyaluronate)
Trade Names: Hyalovet (Fort Dodge), Hylartin V (Pharmacia & Upjohn), Legend (Bayer Animal Health)
http://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/animaldrugsatfda/details.cfm?dn=14...

Ingredient Name: pyrantel tartrate
Trade Name: Strongid C and Banminth (Pfizer), Purina® Horse & Colt Wormer (Virbac AH, Inc.)
http://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/animaldrugsatfda/details.cfm?dn=04...

Ingredient Name: nitrofurazone
Trade Names: NFZ Puffer (Hess & Clark, Inc.), Fura Ointment (Farnam Companies, Inc.)
NFZ Puffer: http://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/animaldrugsatfda/details.cfm?dn=01...
Fura Ointment: http://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/animaldrugsatfda/details.cfm?dn=10...

Ingredient Name: polysulfated glycosaminoglycan (PSGAG)
Trade Name: Adequan (Luitpold Pharmaceuticals, Inc.)
http://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/animaldrugsatfda/details.cfm?dn=14...

Ingredient Name: clenbuterol HCl
Trade Names: Ventipulmin® Syrup (Boehringer Ingelheim)
http://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/animaldrugsatfda/details.cfm?dn=14...

Ingredient Name: tolazoline HCl
Trade Name: Tolazine (Lloyd, Inc.)
http://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/animaldrugsatfda/details.cfm?dn=14...

Ingredient Name: moxidectin
Trade Name: Quest® 2% Equine Oral Gel and Quest® Gel (Fort Dodge)
http://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/animaldrugsatfda/details.cfm?dn=14...

Ingredient Name: ponazuril
Trade Name: Marquis™ Antiprotozoal Oral Paste (Bayer Animal Health)
http://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/animaldrugsatfda/details.cfm?dn=14...

This is only a partial list. Please visit the FDA's website for more information on the proper use of medication for horses. http://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/animaldrugsatfda/

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jan 9, 2013

Horses are suffering due to people that mean well but are not really in tune with the reality of the situation. A good horse is now almost impossible to give away and all horses are not "good" which means not suitable for people to be around. Horses are starved, abandoned, dropped and even turned out on the public right of ways. There are horror stories, true or not, of horses that have to make the trip to slaughter houses in Mexico or Canada.
I'm a rancher and horse owner and I support USDA inspections and am for the humane treatment of all animals but realistically horses are worse off now than they were previously and it's time to come to some good common sense in dealing with this issue.

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jan 10, 2013

"There are horror stories, true or not, of horses that have to make the trip to slaughter houses in Mexico or Canada." There are Horror stories as well during the time that horse slaughter took place on US soil.. all of them true, and they are documented (anon-kh) : http://www.kaufmanzoning.net/foia.htm

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jan 9, 2013

What is wrong with a breeding fee, a license to own, a tax on racing, a fee on auctions, a equine tax ? People are missing the point. Horsemeat is dangerous to herd all these sick unwanted wild sick healthy stolen horses together -you are just asking for ruin to our cattle industry. Competition for resources, trucking, sales, markets, vets, inspections, meds, innoculations, feed, hay, and WATER. When you lose your water and grazing to horse killers raising and collecting any and all - the consquences will "kill" the USDA Beef reputation. Protect the reputation - last thing is another Mad Horse Disease shut down which will spill over! And all for 1% of the horse population so kill buyers can sell to Europe .

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jan 10, 2013

Another aspect of Slaughtering Horses that will hurt the "Live Horse Industry"..the additional costs involved not only at the tax payer level , but the individual owner(s) level , in order to export to the EU (the largest market)USA would be required to form and use the New & Complete Passport System. Having to Use a Lic. Vet. and pay their fees for doing something as simple as a worming, is a burden that in the end will result in more Horses being displaced due to even higher costs burdening ownership for every single horse owner. ""Next year, European Union regulations for exports of horse meat go into effect. By Aug. 1, the U.S. must have a “passport” program in place to track the medications and products used on our horses. This document must be assigned to the horse before it is 6 months old and must accompany the horse for life. Every medication and product must be administered by a veterinarian and documented. That means any de-wormer — if your horse starts to colic, you would not be able to administer banamine without a veterinarian. If the horse receives any medication from the banned list, that horse must be deemed unacceptable for slaughter for human consumption. Implementing a program like this would take more funding from our government, more personnel and, frankly, we can’t afford it." (anon-kh)

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jan 16, 2013

Horses were not brought into this country as companion animals, or "pets." We have made them that way. Horse slaughter needs to happen for many reasons, and unless you understand how in-depth livestock production is you probably won't get why people support it. It really has nothing to do with exports or sending the meat overseas- this is just a niche market we (the US) could take advantage of. By allowing horse slaughter the condition of horses would improve over the nation for points already said above. Feed costs and proper disposal is a HUGE issue for most.

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jan 16, 2013

"Horse slaughter needs to happen for many reasons" "Feed costs and proper disposal is a HUGE issue for most." And for most consumers using the Human Food Chain as a "Disposal" for animals not raised as food is a HUGE issue..slaughter for human consumption is to produce food not to dispose of animals "for many reasons" . So No I will never get why some people support it.

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jan 16, 2013

I think this vompany is stupid and they are only trying to cost us to pay more money to them because cant make money off a horse no more. I read one comment here and really chapped but ...... S about what,they said. The way people think is down right stupid and ignorent. Its never been the horses fault,, it the peoples fault for all of these horses, everybody is breeding them to make money thinking they,will have a million dollar horse and seldom the outcome to many time and now people turn to slaughtering these unwanted horses, I think it crap that people cant admit that they screwed this up by breeding to many horses. I think , county,state and feds need to get together and regulate breeding of horses by either banning breeding of horses for a certain period of time but be aggresive about enforcing laws on breeding horses.
Like one person commented about the need for slaughter, what are we to do give horses like blm mustang program that we spend alot of money every year, no they said slaughter was only way, my thinking if people think that way, maybe we should slaughter people on welfare system in our country and sell them to other countries for slaughter because they cost us money every month instead of pulling there own weight, I think not because its not right and neither is horse slaughter. So all of the people out there for slaughtering of innocent horses and probalbly the very ones that made us over populate the horses because could make money either way, kiss my a..ss and I hope our government shuts you all down and I am one person and it will be one person to be heard and you will lose this battle by far, I wish they all go under the wayside I am glad they cant produce horse meat for other countries and I know others will stsnd behind what I am saying, burn in hell horse slaughter lovers.

Post new comment
Sign In or register to use your BEEF Magazine ID
(optional)

BEEF Newsletter Sign Up

Search 2.5+ million listings