What is in this article?:
- Communicating Correctly Is Key For Family Ranches
- Choosing not to be defensive
Receiving criticism without becoming defensive is hard enough to do under any circumstance. Throw in family dynamics and it can be nearly impossible.
There are untold ways that people show disapproval. Some may raise their voices, others roll their eyes, some use sarcasm. From bouts of anger to withdrawal and pouting, this list is indeed long. How do we react when we are the object of someone’s reproach? Do we become defensive? I’d venture to say we are most likely to feel self-protective when the person showing his or her disapproval is someone we care about. Feelings of defensiveness are likely to result in a similar response, with our own show of displeasure. If this cycle isn’t reversed, accusation, counter-accusation and resentment intensify.
Let’s discuss some tools to help individuals stop seeing others as antagonists, and transform some of the ugliest attacks – real or perceived – into something constructive.
Moving away from defensiveness
In his book and DVDs titled “Nonviolent Communication: A Language of Life,” Marshall Rosenberg explains that we can overcome defensiveness when we stop hearing criticism (even if it was intended) and begin, instead, to listen for unmet needs. It’s so liberating to see in other people’s behavior and communication a set of unfulfilled needs rather than personal attacks. He calls this “receiving empathically.”
Say a person shouts at you, uses sarcasm or manipulative tactics, or says things that you may experience as inconsiderate and hurtful. As long as you focus on your wounded feelings, the chances of a thoughtful response greatly diminish. Most likely, you end up saying something spiteful and insensitive back, and the defensive-aggressive cycle continues. Or, you may be left not knowing what to say and be accused of refusing to talk. Either way, it seems like a losing proposition.
Rosenberg suggests that instead of focusing on how we’re receiving a message, we can concentrate on the person’s implicitly suggested unmet needs (e.g., desire for acceptance, safety, order, appreciation, contribution, trust, etc.). We can thus break the cycle of defensiveness as we communicate back to others what we sense they are feeling (e.g., fear, hurt, worry) and needing. Rosenberg explains, “I think you’ll find people to be less threatening if you hear what they’re needing rather than what they’re thinking about you.”
We may become overly sensitive when we permit ourselves to analyze how others are expressing themselves toward us. In essence, we are burdening ourselves with other people’s imperfect communication patterns. If your intentions have ever been misunderstood – or if you’ve ever done the same when hearing others – you know that even in the best of circumstances, effective communication is not easy. For me, the “aha moment” came when I realized that someone’s ineffective – and at times dysfunctional – communication is more about him or her than about what I may have done or said. The concept may seem deceptively simple.