“Beta-agonists represent a technology that’s been used for a decade in the beef industry, and for longer in the swine industry,” Thomson emphasizes. “I commend Tyson for taking a needed stand for beef cattle welfare. I also commend Merck for pulling the product off the market until the industry can understand what is causing these issues. Dilemmas are only managed, but problems are solved. These groups are stepping forward to find a solution.”

When FPS was becoming an issue at swine slaughter facilities, Thomson says Elanco changed the label for ractopamine, reducing the maximum dose allowed and placing an FPS warning label on the product.

“Elanco also conducted research that showed animal handling, at the time of loading hogs onto trucks to be transported to slaughter — regardless of ractopamine in the diet — was a key to preventing FPS,” Thomson says. “Its research also showed that reducing transport stress from the swine unit to the slaughter facility can be a contributor to FPS occurrence. Management of these issues, along with a reduction in ractopamine feeding levels, has contributed to reducing the incidence of FPS.”

Thomson emphasizes cattle and cattle management have changed since the introduction of beta-agonists. Cattle are heavier, for one thing, with more average weight packed on cattle in the name of production and cost efficiencies. Based on genetic trends, cattle entering the feedlot have more potential for postweaning growth, too.

“Directly, beta-agonists increase heart rates and serum creatinine phosphokinase concentrations [a stress indicator] in cattle,” Thomson says. “Indirectly, feeding beta-agonists could cause metabolism issues [digestive upsets and laminitis] through altered feeding times and delivery management of certain rations to certain animals coming on and going off the product. This change in schedule and feed delivery management could contribute to digestive upsets.”

Although Tyson’s concerns were obviously directed at market-weight cattle in its plant, Thomson says evidence from cattle feeders shows certain types of cattle receiving beta-agonists at particular times of the year may demonstrate an increasing risk of morbidity or mortality during the last month of the feeding period.

Management in feedlots has changed, too. Thomson says sorting cattle into harvest groups is more common today, meaning that every head in a load is bumping against the razor-thin line between just right and too done. For that matter, heavier cattle mean that fewer head make a load. Thomson wonders if the extra room means more jostling and could add stress.

If you add heat stress on a too-hot day, too much distance between the finish pen and feedlot load-out, stressful handling at load-out, a lengthy haul to the packing plant, time spent in packer holding pens during hot weather, too long of a walk on concrete from those pens to the knock box, Thomson believes the combined effect of these and other stressors are creating FCS in some cattle, leading to the ambulatory concerns that prompted the current debate.

Rather than a step backward, though, Thomson views the beta-agonist debate as an opportunity for the beef industry to move farther ahead.

“It will revolutionize the way we manage fed cattle at the end of the finishing period,” Thomson says. “When steroid implants were first introduced in the 1950s, it led to more research into the growth physiology of beef cattle than had ever been done. I think we’ll see a similar result from this discussion. I think you’re going to see a lot of research into cattle physiology and cattle management during the last 30 days before harvest.”

First, though, Thomson stresses, “You don’t know what abnormal is until you know what normal is. As an industry, we haven’t yet discussed or decided upon what normal is when it comes to cattle well-being at each stage of production. We all want to do what is right for the cattle and the beef industry.” 

 

You might also like:

Temple Grandin Explains Animal Welfare Problems With Beta-Agonists

Good Times For Livestock, But Not For Beef

BEEF Honors 50 Innovative Industry Leaders

Cargill Closure Announcement, How Much Can The Industry Afford?

Enjoy A Laugh! Rubes Cartoon Gallery