AmericanCowman.com - Dedicated to America's family cattle operations.

Most Recent

Cow Calf Weekly

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter... It's FREE!

Online Exclusives

More On The Colorado State Fair ID Fiasco


         Subscribe in NewsGator Online   Subscribe in Bloglines

I'm writing in response to Troy Marshall's Sept. 7 article, "Follow-Up On The Colorado State Fair's Great Blunder." Marshall asserts that "The rules were legitimate, they were clearly understood, and they were intentionally broken, after which they simply were not enforced."

Did he actually read the Colorado State Fair (CSF) rule? Rule number 7 on page 4 of the Junior Livestock Rules states: "All 4-H and FFA project animals must have a premises ID number on the entry summary form."

  • Nowhere in the rule document is it stated that the premises ID number has to be a National Animal Identification System (NAIS) number, or that the premises ID number is to be for the location where the animals are housed.

  • Nowhere in the rule document is it stated where an individual should go to obtain a premises ID number.

  • Nowhere in the rule document is a "valid premises ID number" ever defined.
I find it hard to believe that a rule written as ambiguously as this one could be "clearly understood."

Do you think waiting until the eve of the sale and then telling children they must either sign up their parents' property as a premises under NAIS or not sell their animal might be considered placing a child under duress? Perhaps the CSF could have clarified that a "valid" premises ID number actually meant an NAIS number, and that the number must be for the location where the animals in question were housed prior to telling children they had qualified for the livestock sale.

-- Leellen Koroulis
Steamboat Springs, CO.

Get Copyright Clearance Want to use this article? Click here for options!
© 2008 Penton Media Inc.

Browse Back Issues

BQS: View Details and Register Online!

American Cowman

www.AmericanCowman.com

Latest Jobs

Marketplace Ads

  • Hubbard Feeds, Inc

    Download free tools, sign-up for newsletters, browse nutrition products.

  • Your ad Here!

    Advertise your business here! Find out how.

  • Ag Maps for sale

    Ag Maps for Sale!

Resources

  • Western Art Prints
  • Beef Quality Summit
  • 2007 Fencing Guide
  • 2008 Feed Composition Tables
  • Cattlemen's Calendar
  • Biosecurity
  • 2007 Alliance Yellow Pages
  • Estate Planning
  • Calf Health
  • RFID Suppliers
  • State of the Industry
  • Free Product Info